“Nor any drop to drink.”

LM Ruhland, 2008 MCPP intern

Skeptical Inquirer’s Benjamin Radford has a good article about water shortages and why we aren’t actually running out of water.  In a nutshell– the hydrologic cycles don’t ever just stop; there’s not a whole lot of water that ever actually leaves earth.  It just gets more expensive to make it useful.  Everything there is applicable in the ongoing debate about the commodification of Great Lakes water, so I encourage you to take a look.  The science is presented in easily digestible chunks.

Mackinac Center Current Comment : : 23 June 2008

<>< Josh Rule : : 2008 MCPP Intern

Read the Mackinac Center’s current comment for today, 23 June 2008, although it is actually posted on Michigan Education Report.  The article is about a new Catholic high school opening in Detroit this fall.  A well-defined work-study program allows students to earn nearly 70% of their own tuition and leave with four jobs to list on their resume.  The new school is significant because more than 1,000 Catholic schools around the nation have shut down in the past 20 years and few have opened.  Check it out.

Up Is Up

-Hannah Mead, MCPP intern, 2008

(Or, in Michigan’s case, down is down.)

As I crawled through legislative records, I found this charming provision in the Michigan Consumer Protection Act of 1976:

(1) Unfair, unconscionable, or deceptive methods, acts, or practices in the conduct of trade or commerce are unlawful and are defined as follows:

(z) Charging the consumer a price that is grossly in excess of the price at which similar property or services are sold.

I, for one, am certainly glad to know that it’s not only economically impossible for me to sell a pencil for $1000 but illegal as well. While we’ve got the laws of supply and demand mandated in legislation, we may as well codify scientific laws. Why don’t they legislate that all goods displayed in stores are to rest on the top of the shelves instead of magically floating above them?

And in other news, Generalissimo Francisco Franco is still dead.

Lauren Ruhland, 2008 MCPP intern

It’s not all that shocking, but a new survey says that Michiganders don’t think very highly of their elected officials:

Michigan’s citizens hold their government leaders in low regard, at or near the bottom in rankings of Midwest state residents surveyed by a group of government reform advocacy organizations released Thursday.

Only 11% of those surveyed in Michigan said the Legislature was doing a good job, lowest of respondents from five states (Illinois, Michigan, Minnesota, Ohio and Wisconsin). The 2008 Midwest Political Reform Survey found that 21% of the state’s residents thought Gov. Jennifer Granholm was doing a good job.

I have to point out that the sample size is pretty small–400 Michiganders and 1600 in other Midwestern states– but the results sound plausible to me.  Unsurprisingly, the respondents’ four biggest concerns for Michigan are gas prices, jobs, the economy and health care.  As Hannah mentioned yesterday, the governor is already working on the first one.  The survey doesn’t distinguish between dissatisfaction over legislative overaction vs. inaction, but it’s probably safe to assume that most unhappy Michiganders would like to see more government intervention in these issues, not less.

(And if you were wondering about that headline…)

Water, Water, Everywhere

Wetlands in Michigan. Photo by David Kenyon of the Michigan Department of Natural Resources.Over at the Mackinac Center, Russ Harding just released a paper on the difficulties Hart Enterprises, a medical device manufacturer just north of Grand Rapids, is having because of an area on their property that the DEQ is claiming as a wetland.  Give it a read.

Or, for the more visually oriented, check out this video of Harding talking with Charlie Curtis.  Curtis was prohibited from filling in a drainage ditch on his property, because it was ruled a navigable waterway.

Both of these issues are related to the state’s treatment of standing water on a person’s property.  In many cases, it absolutely cripples the owner’s ability to use the land as he pleases.  That is, the owner no longer truly owns the land because of the severe restrictions the government puts on its usage.  For lovers of liberty, true property rights are an absolute necessity and must be defended against these types of regulations. The conservation of our natural resources, including wetlands, is important, but it is more important that we conserve our property rights in the process.

<>< Josh Rule : : 2008 MCPP Intern

Open Source Software: Wealth vs. Money

Money is not Wealth(Note: This is post 2 of a multi-part series about Open Source Software (OSS), and what the idea of Open Sourcing means economically. Read post 1.)

Money is not wealth.  Money is typically just a collection of little bits of metal and paper with all sorts of designs scrawled across them.  It has very little value of its own.  Consequently, economists are not concerned with money, except as a tool for measuring wealth.  And, while it is a fairly common way to measure wealth, money is not the only tool people use to determine value.  In the Open Source world, money is one of the least common currencies of wealth. Continue reading

SAY IT AIN’T SO!

-Hannah Mead, MCPP 2008

You knew it was coming: Antitrust legislation that completely violates every notion of justice and economic sense: Granholm Announces Legislation to Help Protect Consumers at the Pump.

Here’s the appalling part:

The legislation would amend the Michigan Consumer Protection Act by granting the attorney general the ability to issue a civil investigative demand against companies believed to be in violation of the act without having to first obtain a court-ordered subpoena based on probable cause. And the legislation would clearly define what is considered to be a grossly excessive price for goods and services. With these amendments, the attorney general would be able to more efficiently and readily investigate a potential violation of the act, including consumer complaints against the gasoline industry for price-gouging. [emphasis mine]

So now we can sue companies whenever we’d rather pay a cheaper price. I can’t even believe this — and you know it’ll pass.

Continue reading

Don’t Call Sweden Anytime Soon

Swedish FlagsPhoto from swedish-flag.com.

Sweden just passed what has been called “Europe’s most far-reaching eavesdropping plan.“  It allows Saepo, the country’s intelligence agency, to scan international telecommunications (phone calls, faxes, and emails).  The police still need a court order to tap these communications, but Saepo can listen in whenever they feel the need to do so.  I have already written about the potential problems with cellphone monitoring, so I do not think I need to go into too much detail as to why people should not be monitored without express consent.  Quite simply, it erodes liberty.  It takes away a person’s freedom not to be able to control who is listening in on his conversation.  Continue reading

Unemployment :: May 2008

The numbers for May have been released, and they are not exactly great.  Nationally, the unemployment rate was at 5.5% in the month of May.  In itself, that is bad news, seeing as how the annual average just last year was only 4.6%.  However, the more disturbing news is that Michigan’s unemployment rate for May was 8.5%, and Detroit’s was an incredibly high 9.3%.  Michigan has not seen numbers this high since 1992.

To be fair, some of the unemployed are people who just began looking for summer jobs.  Many of them have not been able to find work yet, so the number of unemployed people simply ballooned.  However, that number will only continue to grow tighter for Michigan, because Ford plans to cut 15% of its salary expenses by eliminating many white-collar jobs before the end of the summer.  Exactly what needs to be done to revitalize Michigan’s economy after numbers like these are released, I could not say for sure.  I would love to hear your ideas in the comments, though.

<>< Josh Rule : : 2008 MCPP Intern

“MEGA” Failures in Economic Policy

The Michigan Economic Development Corporation (MEDC) touts the so-called success stories of their efforts today to the tune of 11 new projects slated to generate $179.1 million in new investment and create and retain 3,900 jobs, reports the subscription based MIRSNews.com on June 18th. This of course begs the question; “why do we need an economic development corporation in the first place and what exactly do they do.”

Continue reading

The Cost of a Movie

Roll it!Grand Rapids blog Local Area Watch recently posted a story on how Michigan’s taxpayers are investing in filmmaking.  We have already posted state Representative Chuck Moss’ opinion of the film industry tax break some of Lansing’s lawmakers passed just a few months ago.  The new laws have been decried by both parties, and rightly so.  It appears that Michigan taxpayers will end up shelling out more than $125M in the next year in tax-credit subsidies to try and attract filmmakers to Michigan.  That is not a good idea. Continue reading

Mudflaps and backfiring

-Hannah Mead, MCPP intern, 2008

A concept economists tend to get all wound up about is that of externalities. Externalities are costs or benefits of an action that don’t accrue solely to the actor. For example, the driver of a truck is unaffected by the mud his back tires kick up; that is, he does not bear the full cost of driving, and others bear the negative externality of mud splatters. I don’t know if it’s codified or simply convention, but we use mudflaps to minimize that externality.

Similarly, finding a solution to pollution and other issues of environmental quality is fraught with difficulty. Who ought to bear the cost for what, and how do we find that out and enforce it? This is a valuable question, and, Coase theorem notwithstanding, plagues policymaking. Inefficiency abounds as we fail to figure out how to internalize costs and benefits through either governmental or market means.

At the IHS Koch Summer Fellow Program seminar, the presenters took various angles on this issue, but most agreed externalities are likely a market failure. Dr. Mark Pennington, however, made a strong and, imho brilliant, point: “Politics is the art of externalizing costs.” We do well to keep this in mind when automatically looking to the government to address inefficiencies in the economy.

Thought-Provoking

Realizing that the power to tax is the power to destroy, and that the power to take a certain amount of property or income is only another way of saying that for a certain proportion of his time a citizen must work for the government, the authority to impose a tax upon the people must be carefully guarded. It condemns the citizen to servitude.

Calvin Coolidge – 1924

I stare at this quote an average of three and a half minutes each day while I wait for the microwave to nuke my lunch or coffee, and it got me thinking. Who supports taxation?

I still don’t understand – even after reading about how taxes are sexy. To make things more confusing, I’m the well-educated product of a public school system, and I really appreciate the new sidewalks and stop signs that just went up at the end of my street. But the government’s regulation of the amount of water in my toilet is unconstitutional, and even the easy-target sin taxes are indirectly causing situations beginning to resemble government-subsidized terrorism. 

Guess I’ll have to rethink those sidewalks.

Kahryn Rombach – MCPP Intern, Summer 08

Deposit on Water Bottles in MI’s Future?

Possibly, if the Michigan United Conservation Clubs have anything to say about it.

“The same group that pushed for Michigan to become the first state to require deposits on pop bottles wants to expand the law to add deposits to water bottles, and they hope to get it done by the end of the month.

“The Michigan United Conservation Clubs kicked off an initiative today to convince the legislature to add a 10-cent deposit for water bottles. More than 1.1 billion were thrown away in Michigan in 2005, according to the container Recycling Institute.”

Continue reading